Pick any pub in England that’s more than a century old & it’s guaranteed to have some kind of ghost story attached. Parts of The Brocket Arms in Ayot St Lawrence date back to the 14th century so, predictably, it’s said to be teeming with ghosts.
The most commonly sighted ghost is either a monk or a Catholic priest who either hanged himself, was hanged, or was burned alive. The stories – as nearly-one-thousand-year-old stories will – differ; the most complete (although not necessarily true) account of who the spectre might be has it that the pub was originally the Monastic Quarters for the Norman church, until the Reformation – and that’s when the priest was tried and hanged. There is a ruined Norman church directly opposite the pub, so the legend may have some basis in fact. Descriptions of the apparition vary as much as his mysterious origins: some people have seen a whole ghostly man, others merely a face, & in some versions the monk appears to be on fire. The ghost also apparently makes himself known by moving things about or simply hanging around as a “presence” that sensitive people are able to feel.
The pub’s accommodation – it offers several ensuite bedrooms in the main building, and several more in another building across the courtyard – is also said to be plagued by ghosts, with disembodied footsteps, thuds, and phantom conversations being heard throughout the property.
On a sunny day in May, though, there’s very little that’s spooky about the Brocket Arms. It’s a charming black & white building, with exposed beams & low ceilings throughout. The courtyard is filled with picnic tables where punters can grab a quick snack from the smoky barbecue (offerings included Aberdeen Angus cheeseburgers or wild boar & apple sausages); bar snacks are available in the bar; & the small but perfectly formed menu in the restaurant is to die for. Starters included scallops or “Brocket particular”, a particularly tasty pea & ham soup, while main courses included broad bean & asparagus risotto, steak with all the trimmings, & a mouthwateringly beautiful pan-roasted trout. As for dessert, CJ & I shared a chocolate fondant with raspberry sorbet, & it was the richest, chocolatiest, fruitiest, melting-on-the-plate-but-also-in-your-mouth orgasmic dessert I’ve ever tasted.
Beyond the pub itself, there are lots of stories about local creepy goings-on. The ruined Norman church opposite looks imposingly sinister, with its decayed graveyard, and legend has it that there’s a tunnel underneath the Brocket Arms that leads to Minsden Chapel, another spooky ruined church. The Brocket Arms is also mere minutes away from Shaw’s Corner, George Bernard Shaw’s house, which he is rumoured to haunt. The whole area is a ghosthunter’s dream.
The sheer number of stories are probably explained by the fact that these buildings are so utterly remote, accessible only by mile after mile of winding country roads. It’s the kind of place that gets pitch dark at night, because there’s no light pollution & very little through traffic. It’s beautiful out there, surrounded by acres of stunning English countryside, but it’s also the sort of place you’d feel like ghosts & ghouls might legitimately linger, in tumbledown buildings that have outlived generations.
Last visited 23 May 2010
Example menu: £20.95 for two courses, £25.95 for three courses
Website; Google Maps ref






